Back

How Accessible are Public Services to Disabled People in Tashkent city?

15 May, 2024
Section: Op-ed, Public Scholar

Inaccessible ramp of the Yunusabad district Centre for Public Services in Tashkent.

Photo: Sharoit Plus

Monitoring showed different levels of accessibility of public service centres in Tashkent for disabled citziens. Why are public services provided differently in one city? I wrote an op-ed for Gazeta.uz showing that the problem can be solved by adopting and enforcing government standards of public service delivery to disabled people in Uzbekistan.

Public service centres (PSCs) play an important role in providing necessary services to persons with disabilities and other vulnerable categories of the population. Through the Unified Portal of Interactive Government Services (my.gov.uz), you can submit online applications for the appointment of social benefits, obtaining a medical certificate for the provision of assistive devices and other services without leaving your home.

From November 1, 2021, the provision of public services to persons with disabilities of groups I and II is carried out with a 50% discount on state duties, fees and any other payments. Moreover, persons with disabilities of groups I and II, children with disabilities, as well as citizens caring for them have the right to priority service when receiving government services. But how convenient and accessible is the process of obtaining public services for persons with disabilities?

To answer this question, in April, representatives of the Public Association of Disabled People of Tashkent “Sharoit Plus” conducted a monitoring of the accessibility of public service centres in Tashkent city. The goal is to understand the current state of provision of public services to persons with various forms of disabilities living in the capital. The monitoring selectively covered three public service centres in Yunusabad, Shaykhantakhur and Chilanzar districts.

Sharoit Plus experts checked the PSCs for physical accessibility for persons with disabilities and people with limited mobility, accessibility of information and communication, as well as digital accessibility of the my.gov.uz portal and its mobile application. Moreover, the attitude of PSC employees when providing public services to persons with various forms of disability was assessed.

There are no conditions at Yunusabad – only priority service

At the Yunusabad district PSC, the monitoring team encountered physical and communication barriers. The ramp built at the entrance does not comply with ShNK 2.07.02−22 “Design of construction projects taking into account the needs of persons with disabilities and the elderly” – the angle of inclination exceeds the norm of 5 degrees, the surface is slippery, a wheelchair user will not be able to get into the building on their own.

Even if a disabled person is able to get up the ramp with outside help, he will find himself in the so-called “trap.” The addition of a doorway at the entrance to the centre blocked the passage from the ramp. So there is a ramp, but it’s impossible to use it, and even if you climb it, you won’t be able to enter the building.

The marble covering of the ramp at the entrance to the Shaykhantakhur PSC can be dangerous for people with limited mobility due to the slippery surface

“When I asked a public services specialist in the Yunusabad district about the conditions created for people with disabilities, I was told that they do not have any conditions and only have a priority service for people with disabilities to use the services without a queue. But then, as a person with disability group II, I was put on the general queue,” says a member of the monitoring group.

Many public service centres in the capital have posters about priority services for persons with disabilities. They depict visible forms of physical disability. However, in our society, there is still a widespread stereotypical understanding and image of “disability” as a person in a wheelchair, and many do not take into account the presence of invisible forms of disability.

These are conditions that are not always visible from the outside, but can significantly affect a person’s life. Therefore, posters alone about priority services for persons with disabilities are not enough. PSC staff must be trained to provide services to individuals with invisible disabilities.

Poster about priority service for persons with disabilities at the entrance to Shaykhantakhur PSC

“When I was at the public services centre, they told me that I was 28th in the general queue. When I said that I was entitled to priority service out of the queue, the employees said that I would not be able to a priority service,” says a girl with albinism and group II visual impairment.

A girl with albinism can move freely and communicate with employees of the public services centre. But she has a disability – her condition does not allow her to stand in line on hot days, which can negatively affect her health. Invisible disabilities can include hard of hearing and deaf people, people with intellectual and mental disabilities, and people with chronic illnesses.

“As far as I know, there is a 50% discount on government services for disabled people of groups I and II. But at the Central State Administration of the Shaykhantakhur district they deliberately did not tell me about this,” says a man with a hearing disability of group II.

There is a possibility that not all PSC employees are aware of the regulatory rules regarding priority and preferential services for users with disabilities. Such problems arise due to the lack of systematic training of personnel in the provision of public services to persons with disabilities.

At the Yunusabad district PSC there were also no special surdo-online tablets to ensure communication with persons with hearing disabilities. The surdo-online program was launched in test mode in November 2020. It allows deaf and hard of hearing citizens to communicate with employees of the public services centre through a sign language interpreter online. To ensure such communication, tablets were introduced in 11 capital central state institutions.

It turned out that the work of surdo-online has not been systematically implemented in all public service centres and has even been suspended at the present time. The question of training CSU employees to use the surdo-online program also remains open.

“Our surdo-online system was launched in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic with the assistance of the Ministry of ICT. We provided services on the basis of a one-year contract, and also began servicing public service centres in other regions. We started providing services again last year, but now our work has stopped. The director has changed, and now the PSCs are under the jurisdiction of the Public Services Agency. The surdo-online program continues to work, but we have not concluded a new agreement for the provision of services and therefore we are not paid a subscription fee,” explained Guzal Rakhmatullaeva, director of TECHNO LAB PRO LLC, which has the rights to the surdo-online software.

There are conditions at Chilanzar

“The Chilanzar District Centre for Public Services has created very good conditions for people who use wheelchairs, people with hearing disabilities and people of short stature,” a member of the accessibility monitoring commission shares his/her assessment.

At the entrance to the Chilanzar PSC there is an accessible ramp for users of wheelchairs and other categories of the population with limited mobility. The ramp meets the basic requirements of urban planning standards and regulations in accordance with 2-§ ShNK 2.07.02−22. Moreover, the centre has a wheelchair available in case people with limited mobility need it.

Accessible ramp at the entrance to the Chilanzar district centre of public services

The centre staff were friendly and explained in detail all the conditions created for people with disabilities. The PSC has installed a communication programme surdo-online for deaf and hard of hearing people. The waiting room has furniture that accommodates the needs of a short stature.

A tablet for communication with people with hearing impairments via the surdo-online system

The Chilanzar PSC did not have information in easy-to-read text format for persons with mental and intellectual disabilities. The presence of such an accessible format would eliminate communication barriers to obtaining important information about the public services provided.

An easy-to-read text would be accessible not only to people with disabilities, but also to older people, people with reading and writing disabilities (for example, dyslexia), foreigners who do not fully speak the state language, and other categories.

An example of a successful case of ensuring the accessibility of a central government service is the centre in the Nukus region of Karakalpakstan, equipped with the support of a joint project of the Ministry of Justice, the EU and the UNDP to improve public services.

Is there digital accessibility on the my.gov.uz portal?

A single portal of interactive government services needs careful monitoring of digital accessibility for persons with different forms of impairments. The big question is how convenient is registration through the OneID system and how registration through this system could be simplified. For example, people with disabilities often encounter problems with authorisation using a captcha.

In today’s world, digital accessibility already means much more than having a “version for the visually impaired” or a “audio narrator”. Non-visual accessibility is especially important for blind and visually impaired users. For example, on the my.gov.uz portal there may be visual elements not described alternatively to text (alt-text – description of images in words), which makes it difficult to use the service using screen readers (special programs such as NVDA, VoiceOver in iOS and TalkBack in Android, who voice everything that is shown on the screen of a computer or mobile device).

“Unsigned controls, dynamically changing content, the use of many decorative elements that are not ignored by screen readers, non-standard markup – all this greatly complicates the use of the my.gov.uz portal as well as its mobile application. Existing functionality such as a version for the visually impaired, or an “audio narrator” do not solve these problems and, in my opinion, are unnecessary. Increasing the font, changing the contrast or “screen reader” – all this is already built into all popular operating systems; you just need to rework the user interface so that existing screen readers can adequately recognise and read the content,” one of the members of the monitoring group shared his opinion with Group I visual disability.

There is no need to reinvent the wheel to ensure digital accessibility. A global standard has been developed to ensure accessibility of web content for persons with disabilities – Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.2. This guide includes detailed recommendations to make websites and applications more accessible to users with various types of disabilities, such as visual impairments, hearing impairments, physical disabilities, speech impairments, cognitive impairments and neurological impairments. Unfortunately, the global standard WCAG 2.2 is not widely used in Uzbekistan and is not still recognised at the legislative level.

Unified standard for the provision of public services for disabled people

Providing accessible public services is essential for the active inclusion of disabled people in society. Public services are necessary for all citizens to ensure their full participation in social and political life. It is important to prevent any forms of discrimination based on disability, limited mobility or other factors when receiving services guaranteed by the state.

The preliminary monitoring revealed the strengths and weaknesses of the work with the provision of public services for persons with various forms of impairments. Two institutions were not fully adapted for the movement of persons with physical impairments and people with limited mobility. To obtain a complete picture of the accessibility of public service centres, it is necessary to conduct careful monitoring and examination of the buildings and structures of the Public Services Centres across the country with a view to creating an accessible environment for disabled people.

In the capital alone, the level of accessibility in the three randomly selected PSCs for monitoring is radically different from each other. Such inconsistency in the provision of public services is a consequence of the lack of standardisation in the provision of public services for disabled people and people with limited mobility. There is also a lack of a unified approach to training staff on understanding disability from a social model perspective and proper communication with disabled people, as well as on other issues related to the organisation and accessibility of facilities and services.

A team of experts from a joint project of the Ministry of Justice, the European Union and UNDP in “Improving the provision of public services and increasing the level of governance in rural areas of Uzbekistan” developed a preliminary version of the state standard “Provision of public services for persons with disabilities.” The document includes nine sections, covering detailed information about the basic requirements, conditions and forms of ensuring accessibility of buildings, information and communication, etiquette and treatment in the provision of public services for persons with disabilities. The standard was prepared taking into account international experience and in accordance with the regulatory legal acts of Uzbekistan.

For example, in many developed countries, a responsible employee is hired to ensure the accessibility of the facility and public services and staff staff training in the institution. Job descriptions for such an employee (access/accessibility officer) are separately developed and approved. Government agencies actively cooperate with disabled people’s organisations (DPOs) to ensure that they regularly monitor and independently evaluate the services provided. DPOs also provide training to staff of government agencies.

The adoption and application of a single standard by public service centres throughout the country would avoid the existing fragmentation in the provision of services to persons with various forms of impairments. Compliance with a unified standard for the provision of public services for disabled people would also ensure compliance with the requirements of the law “On the Rights of Persons with Disabilities”, as well as the principles and provisions of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, ratified by Uzbekistan on June 7, 2021.

According to the Convention, persons with disabilities must have equal opportunities to exercise their rights and freedoms in all spheres of life, including the equal right to receive all necessary services to meet their needs in various spheres of life.