Back

“Bring someone sighted!”: How an internal notary regulation outweighed the law in Uzbekistan

16 August, 2026
Section: Op-ed, Public Scholar
Scene: Classic scales of justice, but they are broken or tipped in the wrong direction. On one scale pan lies a bright, solid book bearing the inscription "QONUN" (Law) and a facsimile stamp. On the other, heavier pan sits a small but visually heavy stack of stapled papers bearing the inscription "Ichki yo'riqnoma" (Internal regulation). Details: A confused person with a white cane stands next to the scales. Emotion: Legal paradox (when a regulation turns out to be heavier than the Law).

Illustration: Eldos Fazylbekov

People with visual impairments face systematic discrimination when accessing notary services in Uzbekistan. Local notaries refuse to accept legally recognised facsimile signatures, demanding that a representative from the Society of the Blind of Uzbekistan be brought in. Together with Abdullo Abdukhalilov we called for the system to be changed and wrote an op-ed for Gazeta.uz

On July 24, Abdullo, who has had a visual impairment since birth with disability Group I, visited a notary office in the Yashnabad district of Tashkent with his son. He needed to issue a simple power of attorney authorising another person to receive a bank card. However, instead of receiving a public service, he ran into a bureaucratic wall and blatant discrimination based on disability.

The notary refused to process the documents, categorically stating that this required bringing a representative from the Society of the Blind of Uzbekistan. The attempt to resolve the situation on the spot led to even greater absurdity. During a phone call to the Notary Chamber, its employee asked a completely unethical question: “Have you been blind since birth, or did you acquire the disability?” Upon learning that Abdullo had been blind since birth, she confirmed the previously stated requirement to find a mediator from the Society of the Blind.

It turns out that if the visual impairment is acquired, there is no need to summon a representative from the Society of the Blind. This logic-defying regulation makes the situation even more absurd. Unfortunately, this case is not the mistake of a single notary but a systemic problem faced by all people with visual impairments. Today, state regulations effectively turn legally capable, independent citizens into second-class people, depriving them of the right to manage their own lives.

The Law Permits, but the Regulation Prohibits

People with visual impairments are full-fledged and legally competent citizens. They bear full responsibility for their actions. To enable them to sign documents independently, a facsimile—a specially made stamp that replaces a handwritten signature—is used all over the world.

In Uzbekistan, this right is clearly established in Article 29 of the Law “On the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.” The law explicitly states that the facsimile signature of a person with a disability is recognised as an official signature and carries legal force.

Screenshot from Article 29 of the Law “On the Rights of Persons with Disabilities”.

However, in practice, notaries ignore this law. They refer to their internal departmental regulation (paragraph 9 of the 2019 Ministry of Justice regulation on the procedure for performing notarial acts), which categorically prohibits accepting documents with a facsimile signature.

A gross legal conflict arises: a subordinate act of an individual ministry is somehow placed above the law and the Constitution of the Republic of Uzbekistan. According to the Law ‘On Normative Legal Acts’, departmental regulations are subordinate acts and under no circumstances can they contradict laws.

The internal regulation of the Ministry of Justice, being a subordinate departmental act, has no right to cancel or restrict the effect of the Law ‘On the Rights of Persons with Disabilities’, which permits the use of a facsimile. By applying the regulation instead of the law, notaries directly violate Article 15 of the Constitution, which recognises the unconditional supremacy of the laws.

The absurdity of forced ‘intermediaries’

To bypass its own ban on facsimiles, the notarial regulation (paragraph 8) offers visually impaired people a humiliating solution. Another person (a ‘proxy’) must sign the document on behalf of the person with a visual impairment in the presence of a notary, under video recording. At the same time, for some reason, notaries persistently demand that blind people bring representatives specifically from the Society of the Blind.

There is no logic whatsoever in this requirement. Firstly, the majority of employees at the Society of the Blind are themselves blind; how can they act as a sighted proxy? And if a representative who also has a visual impairment comes to the notary as a proxy, will their rights also be infringed? Secondly, by no means all people with visual impairments are members of this organisation. A state service should not depend on whether a person is a member of any NGO or not. This artificially creates a dependency of the blind person on third parties.

Why should the Society of the Blind be the only possible intermediary between notaries and blind citizens? In which normative legal documents is such a role for the Society of the Blind enshrined? And why can only a representative of one specific organisation act as a proxy for a blind person? After all, a person with a visual impairment must have the choice of their trusted representative—whether it be a legal entity or a natural person. Or, overall, to do without any intermediaries when receiving notarial services. All these questions remain open…

Moreover, by imposing the proxy services of a specific organisation, notaries directly violate the Law ‘On Non-Governmental Non-Profit Organisations’. Part 3 of Article 18 of the law clearly states: “The requirement to indicate in official documents membership or participation in the activities of a particular non-governmental non-profit organisation is not permitted. The affiliation or non-affiliation of citizens with an NGO cannot serve as a basis for restricting their rights and freedoms.” It turns out that by refusing service without a representative of the Society of the Blind, the notary system illegally restricts the rights of citizens with visual impairments.

The Ministry of Justice’s response: “You have misunderstood everything”

The Tashkent City Department of Justice sent an official response to Abdullo’s appeal to the President’s virtual reception regarding this incident. In the letter signed by the Deputy Head of the Department, J. Khudoyorov, the agency fully justifies the notary’s actions.

In its response, the department refers to the Administrative Regulation (approved by Cabinet of Ministers Resolution No. 726 of 2020). According to the document, when a blind person applies, the presence of a ‘typhlo-interpreter’ is required, whose credentials must be confirmed by a power of attorney and an official identity card issued exclusively by the Society of the Blind of Uzbekistan. The response concludes by stating that the notary was simply explaining the regulation, and the citizen ‘incorrectly understood this as discrimination’.

This response raises more questions than it answers and exposes the striking incompetence of the system. Firstly, such a profession as a ‘typhlo-interpreter’ simply does not officially exist in Uzbekistan. There are audio describers (specialists who describe visual sequences for the blind). Where is a blind citizen supposed to find a specialist of a non-existent profession? Secondly, the Society of the Blind has no legal authority, mechanisms, or educational facilities to train, certify, or issue identity cards to any ‘typhlo-interpreters’.

Thirdly, the regulation itself (No. 726), referred to by the officials, is written with the grossest logical errors and without the slightest understanding of the specifics of disability. The document indicates that a ‘typhlo-interpreter’ is not needed if the notary knows how to work with a certain ‘device intended for a blind citizen’. Exactly what kind of device is meant is not specified. Is it a Braille display? A screen reader programme (JAWS, NVDA)? A dictaphone? The wording ‘if the notary knows how to work with the device’ (moslama bilan ishlay olsa) dooms the norm to failure from the outset. Not a single notary in the country undergoes training in working with special typhlotechnical aids.

Moreover, the regulation absurdly links this mythical device with the possibility of ‘communication’, although blind people have no problems whatsoever with verbal communication. This legal ‘black hole’ gives the notary a legal loophole: since no one knows what this device is and how to work with it, notaries simply send all blind people away to look for non-existent ‘typhlo-interpreters’.

But the most cynical part of this response is the phrase that the blind person ‘incorrectly understood’ the situation as discrimination. A logical question arises: how can one ‘correctly’ or ‘incorrectly’ feel the infringement of one’s own rights? Why does a justice department official take the liberty of deciding whether the feelings of a person with a disability facing a barrier are justified?

The answer lies in a conflict of interest. A complaint against discriminatory regulations, developed and handed down by the Ministry of Justice, is reviewed by an employee of that very same justice department. Instead of an objective analysis of the problem and the protection of human rights, the system simply stood up to defend its institutional reputation and its own unworkable regulations.

The destruction of the ‘secrecy of a will’ and property rights

The most dangerous consequence of this bureaucracy is the gross violation of fundamental civil and property rights. Imagine that a blind citizen wants to draw up a will to pass on their house or savings to their children. According to Articles 1127 and 1128 of the Civil Code of Uzbekistan, every citizen has an unconditional right to the ‘secrecy of a will’. No one should know of its contents until a certain time.

But the notarial regulation strips blind people of this right. Since a person cannot simply come and affix their facsimile stamp, the system forces them to involve a third party—a stranger who will sign on their behalf. This stranger will inevitably learn all the details and secrets of the will. The confidentiality guaranteed by law is completely destroyed. A blind person is deprived of the basic right to freely, independently, and secretly dispose of their own property.

Why can banks do it, but not the notary system?

Usually, the ban on facsimiles is justified by ‘security considerations’ and protection against fraud. But this argument falls apart if you look at the financial sector.

Banks work with real money, loans, and enormous risks. However, the Central Bank of Uzbekistan resolved this problem a long time ago. According to the official instructions of the CB (in particular, paragraph 30 of Resolution No. 3420), if a person with a disability cannot sign by hand, banks officially permit the use of a facsimile signature when opening accounts and executing documents. Moreover, priority service has been introduced for persons with disabilities in banks, and conditions have been created for the remote signing of contracts.

If a strict and conservative financial system was able to adapt, recognise facsimiles, and ensure equal rights for clients with disabilities, then why does the notary system continue to cling to discriminatory rules?

It is time to change the system!

Blind and visually impaired people are considered fully legally capable citizens with equal rights and can bear full responsibility for their actions. However, the actions of notaries and the internal rules developed for them render blind citizens legally incapacitated. At the same time, a person can only be declared legally incapacitated by a court order.

The blind citizens of Uzbekistan do not need condescension or externally imposed ‘proxies’ to exercise their constitutional rights. They simply need compliance with the law. Uzbekistan ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) in 2021, and its norms take precedence and are binding upon state bodies, including the Ministry of Justice and the Notary Chamber. The Convention prohibits any discrimination on the basis of disability and, to ensure equality, obliges the provision of ‘reasonable accommodation’ for people with disabilities.

The use of a facsimile signature is precisely that ‘reasonable accommodation’ for a blind person, so that they can use services on an equal basis with everyone else. The Convention regards the denial of this accommodation as an act of discrimination on the basis of disability.

To promptly rectify this situation, the Ministry of Justice and the Notary Chamber must urgently review the norms for providing notarial services to persons with disabilities, taking into account their interests and rights.

Our main recommendations include the following measures:

  • To recognise as discriminatory and contrary to the Law ‘On the Rights of Persons with Disabilities’ and the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities paragraph 9 of the Regulation on the Procedure for Performing Notarial Acts, as well as paragraph 18 of the Administrative Regulation (approved by Cabinet of Ministers Resolution No. 726 of 18.11.2020).
  • To officially permit the use of a facsimile signature by blind citizens when receiving any notarial services, ensuring the direct effect of Article 29 of the Law ‘On the Rights of Persons with Disabilities’.
  • To stop the illegal practice of forcing persons with visual impairments to seek representatives exclusively from the Society of the Blind. This requirement grossly violates Article 18 of the Law ‘On Non-Governmental Non-Profit Organisations’. Blind citizens must be granted the unconditional right to independently choose whether or not to involve trusted representatives (natural or any legal persons) to receive the services of a notary.
  • To eliminate from normative legal acts the unfeasible requirements to involve specialists of non-existent professions (‘typhlo-interpreters’), as well as vague norms regarding the use of undefined ‘devices’. Documents must be written with technical and terminological accuracy, with an understanding of the specifics of various forms of disability and, first and foremost, with the direct participation of representatives of disabled people’s organisations themselves.
  • To make regular training mandatory for notary staff on the ethics of communication and standards of service provision for people with various forms of disability. It is essential to directly involve disabled people’s organisations in the development of regulations and the conducting of training, observing the main principle of the UN Convention: ‘Nothing about us without us’.

It is time to stop dividing citizens into those who can manage their lives independently and those who have to ask for a favour from people with a pen to do so. The right to human dignity must be equal for all.

About authors

Dilmurad Yusupov — Postdoctoral Fellow at the University of Tokyo, PhD in Development Studies from the Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex.

Abdullo Abdukhalilov — Acting Professor at the Department of Social Work, National University of Uzbekistan named after Mirzo Ulugbek, Doctor of Sociological Sciences, Deputy Chairperson for Strategic Planning at the Association of Disabled People of Uzbekistan, international expert in the field of inclusion and disability.

The article was first published on 13 August 2026 at Gazeta.uz.